Time to read: 8 minutes
We’re happy to present another live site assessment for IPaintMyMind.org. As a leading non-profit organization, the team at IPaintMyMind helps its partners transform their spaces, deliver creative experiences, and connect through the power of art. In their evaluation above, John discusses high-level opportunities on:
- Increasing website speed
- Adding more Schema markup
- Additional keywords to target
- Meaningful, long-form content
- Enhancing their calls-to-action
Watch their full assessment in the video above, or get the scoop in our summarized version below.
Non-profit organizations face a unique digital marketing challenge: they need to attract donors, engage community members, recruit volunteers, and build partnerships, often all at once and typically with leaner budgets than their for-profit counterparts. That’s exactly why getting the most out of your website matters so much.
Below, we break down each of the five areas covered in the evaluation, with actionable details you can apply whether you run a non-profit, a small business, or anything in between.
1. Website Speed: An Overlooked Conversion Killer
Of all the technical factors that affect both SEO and user experience, page speed is one of the most impactful and often the most overlooked! Research consistently shows that even a one-to-two-second delay in load time can meaningfully reduce engagement and conversions.
For a mission-driven organization like IPMM, this matters on two fronts. A slow site frustrates potential donors who are trying to learn more before giving. And from a search engine standpoint, Google uses Core Web Vitals as a ranking factor. A site that loads slowly can be quietly penalized in search results without the organization ever knowing why.
What to look at:
- Run the site through Google PageSpeed Insights or GTmetrix to identify specific bottlenecks.
- Large, uncompressed images are the most common culprit. Every image on the site should be compressed and, where possible, served in a modern format like WebP.
- Look at whether a caching plugin or CDN (content delivery network) is in place. These can dramatically improve load times for returning visitors and users across different geographies.
- Eliminate or defer any JavaScript that’s blocking the page from rendering above the fold.
Speed improvements at most times don’t require a full site rebuild, but rather a few targeted changes can move the needle significantly.
2. Schema Markup: Speak Search Engines’ Secret Language
Schema markup is structured data code that you add to your website to help search engines better understand what each page is about. It doesn’t change what visitors see on your site, but it tells Google things like what type of organization you are, what different people’s roles are, what you offer, etc.
When implemented well, schema can help Google display things like event dates, organization details, and more directly in the search results. These enhanced listings take up more visual real estate and typically earn higher click-through rates than standard blue links.
Schema types especially relevant for IPaintMyMind:
- Organization schema: Establishes foundational information about IPMM — name, logo, social profiles, and contact info—so Google can correctly represent them across search.
- Event schema: If IPMM hosts or promotes public events, exhibitions, or community programs, event schema allows those to appear directly in search results with dates and locations, which is a significant visibility boost.
- Article schema: Applied to blog posts and editorial content to signal to Google that these are substantive, authored pieces that can support E-E-A-T (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, Trustworthiness) signals.
- FAQ schema: For pages that address common questions about their programs or partnership process, FAQ schema can expand the search listing and answer questions right in the results page.
Schema markup requires some technical implementation, but tools like Google’s Rich Results Test make it easy to verify whether it’s working correctly once added.
3. Keyword Targeting: Getting Found by the Right People
For IPMM, their keyword strategy should be just about driving traffic; it needs to be about reaching the right audiences, such as organizations looking for art programming partnerships, donors searching for impactful Chicago nonprofits to support, artists looking for opportunities, and community members looking for local creative experiences.
Most non-profit sites default to the language they use internally to describe their work. But if your potential partners and donors are using different language when they search, there’s a disconnect.
Areas to expand keyword targeting:
- Service and program pages: Terms like “corporate art programs,” “workplace mural installation,” “creative placemaking Chicago,” or “public art commission” describe what IPMM does in language a prospective partner would actually type.
- Mission-aligned donor searches: People who want to support the arts locally might search for “Chicago arts non-profit to donate to,” “support public art in Chicago,” or “art organizations in Chicago.” These are keywords worth creating content around.
- Artist and community terms: “Chicago mural artists,” “art grants Chicago,” and “community art projects” can attract artists interested in IPMM’s programs.
A good starting point is to look at the site through the lens of each audience: partners, donors, artists, and community members, and ask, “What would this person type into Google to find us?” Then make sure there’s content on the site that answers that query.
4. Long-Form Content: Building Authority Through Depth
Non-profit websites often have a strong visual identity and a compelling mission statement but relatively thin written content outside of their core pages. This is a missed opportunity, both for SEO and for building the kind of trust that turns a curious visitor into a committed supporter.
Long-form content (think 1,000 words or more) signals to search engines that a page is a comprehensive resource worth ranking. But more practically, it gives IPMM the space to tell richer stories, demonstrate impact, and answer the questions that matter most to its different audiences.
Content ideas that would serve IPMM well:
- Impact stories and case studies: A deep dive into a specific partnership, what the client wanted, how IPMM brought the vision to life, and what the outcome meant for the space and community—is compelling reading that also demonstrates credibility.
- “How it works” content: Explaining the process of commissioning a mural, launching an art program, or partnering with them helps prospective partners understand what to expect and reduces hesitation.
- Artist spotlights: Long-form features on artists in the IPMM network serve multiple purposes: they’re shareable, they support artists, and they attract organic search traffic from people interested in those artists’ work.
- Educational content around public art: Pieces like “How Public Art Transforms Workplace Culture” or “What to Consider When Commissioning a Mural” target the early stages of the partner journey, when organizations are still exploring whether and how to invest in art.
- Annual impact reports in web format: Rather than a PDF that disappears from search indexes, a web-based impact report makes IPMM’s outcomes visible and searchable.
The goal is to become the most helpful, authoritative resource on the topics their audiences care about, not just a brochure for the organization.
5. Calls-to-Action: Turning Visitors Into Supporters
Even a well-trafficked website underperforms if visitors don’t know what to do next. For IPMM, a “conversion” looks different depending on who’s visiting: a corporate partner filling out a contact form, a donor completing a gift, an artist submitting a portfolio, or a community member signing up for an event. Each of those journeys needs a clear, intentional path.
Common CTA issues to address:
- Vague language: Generic CTAs like “Learn More” or “Get in Touch” don’t create urgency or communicate value. More specific language works better: “Start a Partnership Conversation,” “Support Public Art in Chicago,” or “Submit Your Art Portfolio.”
- Placement: CTAs should appear above the fold on key pages — meaning a visitor shouldn’t have to scroll to find out how to take action. They should also be repeated at natural pauses throughout longer pages.
- Visual hierarchy: The primary CTA on any given page should visually stand out — through contrast, button styling, or white space — so the eye is naturally drawn to it.
- Audience-specific pathways: The homepage should quickly route different visitor types to the right place. A navigation or hero section that distinguishes “For Partners,” “For Donors,” and “For Artists” can dramatically reduce friction.
- Donation experience: For non-profits specifically, the donation page deserves its own attention. Is it clearly linked from the navigation? Does it offer multiple giving levels with suggested amounts? Is the form mobile-friendly? Friction at the donation step is costly.
A useful exercise: have someone unfamiliar with your brand visit your site and, within 30 seconds, ask them, “What does this organization do, and what am I supposed to do here?” If those questions aren’t immediately answerable, the CTA and messaging structure need work.
Why These Recommendations Apply Beyond Non-Profits
While this evaluation was tailored to IPaintMyMind, the five areas we covered — speed, schema, keyword targeting, long-form content, and CTAs — are relevant to virtually any website trying to grow its organic presence and convert more visitors. Whether you’re a non-profit, a service business, or an e-commerce brand, these are the foundational levers that separate sites that grow through search from sites that stay invisible.
Want Your Website Evaluated?
If you’d like an expert set of eyes on your website, fill out our form, and we’ll be in touch.
